- Europe, like you've never read before -
Thursday, 19 November 2026
No Result
View All Result
  • en ENG
  • it ITA
Eunews
  • Politics
  • World
  • Business
  • News
  • Defence
  • Health
  • Agrifood
  • Other sections
    • Culture
    • Rights
    • Energy
    • Green Economy
    • Finance & Insurance
    • Industry & Markets
    • Media
    • Mobility & Logistics
    • Net & Tech
    • Sports
  • Eunews Newsletter
  • European 2024
    Eunews
    • Politics
    • World
    • Business
    • News
    • Defence
    • Health
    • Agrifood
    • Other sections
      • Culture
      • Rights
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Net & Tech
      • Sports
    No Result
    View All Result
    Eunews
    No Result
    View All Result

    Home » Net & Tech » A social network is not “free” when users are required to provide personal data

    A social network is not “free” when users are required to provide personal data

    The Advocate General’s opinion in the Facebook case is not binding on the judges

    Ezio Baldari</a> <a class="social twitter" href="https://twitter.com/@eziobaldari" target="_blank">@eziobaldari</a> by Ezio Baldari @eziobaldari
    19 November 2026
    in Net & Tech
    META UFFICI UFFICIO INTERNET BIG TECK SOCIAL FACEBOOK INSTAGRAM COMUNICAZIONE LOGO GENERATE AI IA

    META UFFICI UFFICIO INTERNET BIG TECK SOCIAL FACEBOOK INSTAGRAM COMUNICAZIONE LOGO GENERATE AI IA

    Brussels – A social network cannot be described as free if users are required to provide their personal data to use it. This is the view of the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the EU, Laila Medina, in the conclusions in the case pitting a German consumer organisation against Meta. In February 2015, the registration page for Facebook, operated in the EU by Meta Platforms Ireland, stated: “Facebook is free remains free”. The association, the Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband, challenged this statement, arguing that users gain access in exchange for their data and consent to its commercial use.

    The German judges dismissed the appeal, ruling that the ban applies only to cases where the consumer incurs financial costs. Upon receiving the appeal, the Federal Court of Justice sought an opinion from Luxembourg.

    Medina proposes that the Court rule that the disclosure of personal data
    and consent to their commercial use constitute a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices
    Directive.
    A service cannot be described as “free: where consumers are required to provide such
    data for commercial use, unless the data are processed exclusively to ensure the provision of the service or comply
    with legal obligations.

    In her view, the directive does not restrict payment to money, and the Court has already recognised that considerations in other forms may be taken into account provided they have economic value. Data enables the operator to generate advertising revenue and finance the service. Even if the user retains it, therefore, it has economic value. Other EU rules on digital content and consumer rights also recognise the exchange of services for data. Restricting the concept to money would weaken protection in the digital economy, where users are often unaware of the value of their data. Furthermore, for practices that are prohibited in all circumstances, there is no need to verify whether the average consumer has actually been misled.

    The Advocate General rejects Meta’s objections: the GDPR does not preclude the Directive, as the two sets of rules apply concurrently, and companies remain free to offer services in exchange for data, but not to call them free.

    The conclusions are not binding on the Court, which must now deliberate.

    English version by the Translation Service of Withub
    Tags: cortedatifacebookmeta

    Related Posts

    Per la Corte di giustizia UE, un alimento a base di CBD non può beneficiare della certificazione biologica se la sua immissione sul mercato nell’Unione non è stata autorizzata. Source:
    Agrifood

    EU Court says no to ‘organic’ certification for unauthorised CBD foods

    5 November 2026
    Bambini online. Crediti: Vlad Deep via Unsplash
    Net & Tech

    Brussels’ call: “Avoid fragmented legislation across the EU” on child safety online

    23 October 2026
    CYBERSECURITY CYBERSICUREZZA CONTROLLI HACKER  SICUREZZA PROTEZIONE  INFORMATICA DIGITALE DIFESA CIBERNETICA TUTELA DATI DIGITALI GENERATE AI IA
    Business

    Online fraud: bank must immediately reimburse customer, even in cases of negligence

    15 October 2026
    LUIZ INÁCIO LULA DA SILVA PRESIDENTE BRASILE
    World politics

    PD MEPs denounce Zuckerberg’s interference in the Brazilian presidential election

    5 October 2026
    Da sinistra a destra, la vicepresidente esecutiva per la Sovranità tecnologica, la sicurezza e la democrazia, Henna Virkkunen, e la presidente della Commissione europea, Ursula von der Leyen. Crediti: Commissione europea
    Net & Tech

    Children online: the EU Children’s Act is here to protect them from digital risks

    17 September 2026
    L'eurodeputato (S&D), eletto con il Partito Democratico, Sandro Ruotolo. Crediti: Parlamento europeo
    Net & Tech

    Children online, Ruotolo (S&D): “Protecting them without preventing them from accessing the benefits of the internet”

    16 September 2026
    map visualization
    META UFFICI UFFICIO INTERNET BIG TECK SOCIAL FACEBOOK INSTAGRAM COMUNICAZIONE LOGO GENERATE AI IA

    A social network is not “free” when users are required to provide personal data

    by Ezio Baldari @eziobaldari
    19 November 2026

    The Advocate General’s opinion in the Facebook case is not binding on the judges

    L’UE rinvia di due anni gli obblighi sul metano per gli importatori di combustibili fossili

    Methane obligations for fossil fuel importers delayed by two years

    by Annachiara Magenta annacmag
    19 November 2026

    The compromise between the Council and Parliament goes further than the European Commission’s initial proposal, which provided for a one-year...

    Corrado Augias (Imagoeconomica)

    Corrado Augias has died; he was also a Member of the European Parliament – and loved walnuts

    by Redazione eunewsit
    19 November 2026

    He was 91; from Telefono giallo to La Torre di Babele, a Rai journalist who spent years at la Repubblica...

    La presidente della Commissione europea e il re della Giordania,

    EU strengthens its presence in Jordan through new investment opportunities and partnerships

    by Iolanda Cuomo
    19 November 2026

    The various agreements were signed at the EU-Jordan Investment Conference at the Dead Sea. Von der Leyen: “Despite the turmoil...

    • Director’s Point of View
    • Opinions
    • About us
    • Contacts
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie policy

    Eunews is a registered newspaper
    Press Register of the Court of Turin n° 27

    Copyright © 2025 - WITHUB S.p.a., Via Savona 127/B, 20144 Milano
    VAT number: 10067080969 - ROC registration number n.30628
    Fully paid-up share capital 50.000,00€

     

    No Result
    View All Result
    • en ENG
    • it ITA
    • Politics
    • Newsletter
    • World politics
    • Business
    • General News
    • Defence & Security
    • Health
    • Agrifood
    • Altre sezioni
      • Culture
      • Rights
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Gallery
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Net & Tech
      • News
      • Opinions
      • Sports
    • Director’s Point of View
    • Draghi Report
    • Eunews Newsletter

    No Result
    View All Result
    • en ENG
    • it ITA
    • Politics
    • Newsletter
    • World politics
    • Business
    • General News
    • Defence & Security
    • Health
    • Agrifood
    • Altre sezioni
      • Culture
      • Rights
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Gallery
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Net & Tech
      • News
      • Opinions
      • Sports
    • Director’s Point of View
    • Draghi Report
    • Eunews Newsletter

    Attention