- Europe, like you've never read before -
Thursday, 17 July 2025
No Result
View All Result
  • it ITA
  • en ENG
Eunews
  • Politics
  • World
  • Business
  • News
  • Defence
  • Net & Tech
  • Agrifood
  • Other sections
    • Culture
    • Diritti
    • Energy
    • Green Economy
    • Finance & Insurance
    • Industry & Markets
    • Media
    • Mobility & Logistics
    • Sports
  • Newsletter
  • European 2024
    Eunews
    • Politics
    • World
    • Business
    • News
    • Defence
    • Net & Tech
    • Agrifood
    • Other sections
      • Culture
      • Diritti
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Sports
    No Result
    View All Result
    Eunews
    No Result
    View All Result

    Home » Politics » Pfizergate: EU court slams von der Leyen and the European Commission; says they ‘failed to provide credible explanations’

    Pfizergate: EU court slams von der Leyen and the European Commission; says they ‘failed to provide credible explanations’

    The EU executive failed to prove that it did not hold the text messages exchanged between von der Leyen and the Pfizer CEO over the purchase of millions of vaccine doses during the COVID-19 pandemic. Brussels stalls and claims, "Transparency has always been of paramount importance."

    Simone De La Feld</a> <a class="social twitter" href="https://twitter.com/@SimoneDeLaFeld1" target="_blank">@SimoneDeLaFeld1</a> by Simone De La Feld @SimoneDeLaFeld1
    14 May 2025
    in Politics

    Brussels – The EU General Court slaps Ursula von der Leyen over the so-called Pfizergate. The judges in Luxembourg side with the New York Times and annul the decision by which the European Commission rejected access to text messages exchanged between the president and Pzifer’s CEO, Albert Bourla, over the purchase of millions of doses of vaccines during the COVID-19 pandemic. According to the judgment, it is not enough to merely state that it does not hold the requested documents. The EU executive should have “provided credible explanations” to demonstrate why such documents were unavailable. And it did not do so.

    Rewind: in November 2020, amid the health crisis, the Commission and its president von der Leyen began betting on Pfizer vaccines — as well as those of Moderna, AstraZeneca, and Novavax — to kick off the massive vaccine campaign. It purchased 300 million Pfizer doses in January 2021 and 100 million doses in April. A few days later, it announced another contract. There were so many doses and so much money at stake. Matina Stevis-Gridness, a reporter for the New York Times, asked to see the correspondence between the main players in this story, the Commission president and the Pfizer CEO. However, she was denied access because Brussels claimed the text messages were unavailable.

     

    pfizer
    Pfizer CEO, Albert Bourla (Photo by Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP)

    The European Commission does not deny the message exchange between von der Leyen and Bourla, pointing out that it was an “unprecedented situation” and that, at the time, no legislation existed for such contracts with pharmaceutical industries. But the messages “only served to speed up communication,” they say in Brussels in Brussels. The messages were not filed because they contained nothing relevant.

    In their ruling today (May 15), the Luxembourg judges noted that the Commission’s responses throughout the proceedings regarding the requested text messages are based “either on assumptions or on changing or imprecise information.” On the other hand, the New York newspaper presented “relevant and consistent evidence describing the existence of exchanges, in the form of text messages in particular, between the President of the Commission and the CEO of Pfizer in the context of the procurement of vaccines by the Commission from that company during the COVID-19 pandemic.”

    agricoltori von der leyen

    European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen (photo: Frederick Florin via Afp)

    The embarrassment is complete: the EU executive “did not explain in detail the type of searches that it carried out to find those documents” and, in general, “plausible explanation to justify the non-possession of the requested documents.” Another key passage: the Commission has not sufficiently clarified whether the text messages between von der Leyen and Bourla were deleted and, if so, whether the deletion was done “deliberately or automatically” or whether the President’s mobile phone “had been replaced in the meantime.”​ the Tribunal further notes that the Commission’s defense falls apart since it “failed to explain in a plausible manner why it considered that the text messages exchanged did not contain important information.”

    Brussels, which can appeal the ruling to the EU Court of Justice within two months and ten days, is stalling for now. A statement that is as cautious as it is enigmatic says it will “closely study the General Court’s decision” and “decide on next steps.” It will also “adopt a new decision providing a more detailed explanation.”

    English version by the Translation Service of Withub
    Tags: albert bourlacovid19eu court of justicepfizergate

    Related Posts

    La presidente della Commissione europea, Ursula von der Leyen, presenta la proposta di bilancio pluriennale [Bruxelles, 16 luglio 2025. Foto: Emanuele Bonini]
    Politics

    Almost 2 trillion, with CAP and cohesion together: the proposed new 2028–2034 EU budget

    16 July 2025
    Screenshot
    Briefs

    Belgian soldiers to appear incognito at National Day parade

    16 July 2025
    MILANO DALL’ALTO GRATTECIELO UNICREDIT
    Business

    Unicredit-BPM: EU criticizes Italian government, says decree imposing obligations on the bank breaches EU rules

    14 July 2025
    migranti regno unito francia
    Politics

    UK to deport migrants to France—and take in others in return

    11 July 2025
    [foto: JoseAlfredo9710/Wikimedia Commons]
    Business

    E-commerce, also the EU Parliament against duty exemption for products under €150

    9 July 2025
    Salute

    Biological warfare and chemical attacks: EU launches crisis coordination plan

    9 July 2025
    map visualization
    Flourish logoA Flourish map
    Oliver Röpke

    INTERVIEW / Oliver Röpke (EESC): ‘Social dialogue a necessary condition for enlargement’

    by Francesco Bortoletto bortoletto_f
    17 July 2025

    The president of the European Economic and Social Committee explained to Eunews the importance of fully involving civil society in...

    germania uk

    Germany and the UK sign a friendship treaty committing them to defend each other

    by Simone De La Feld @SimoneDeLaFeld1
    17 July 2025

    It is the first bilateral agreement between the two countries: in addition to military assistance, Berlin and London promise cooperation...

    Stéphane Séjourné

    ERAP: new MMF an important step towards a better Europe

    by Sebastian Robustelli Balfour
    17 July 2025

    The European Research Promotion Agency commends the European Commission for "the commitment and vision shown in placing research and innovation...

    Four new infringement procedures, the EU won’t let the Meloni government go on holiday

    by Emanuele Bonini emanuelebonini
    17 July 2025

    Irregularities in taxation regimes and non-transposition in banking and hydrogen: the Commission's tough punch against Italy, against which it adopts...

    • Director’s Point of View
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Opinions
    • About us
    • Contacts
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie policy

    Eunews is a registered newspaper
    Press Register of the Court of Turin n° 27


     

    Copyright © 2025 - WITHUB S.p.a., Via Rubens 19 - 20148 Milan
    VAT number: 10067080969 - ROC registration number n.30628
    Fully paid-up share capital 50.000,00€

     

    No Result
    View All Result
    • it ITA
    • en ENG
    • Politics
    • Newsletter
    • World politics
    • Business
    • General News
    • Defence & Security
    • Net & Tech
    • Agrifood
    • Altre sezioni
      • European Agenda
      • Culture
      • Diritti
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Gallery
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • News
      • Opinions
      • Sports
    • Director's Point of View
    • L’Europa come non l’avete mai ascoltata
    • Draghi Report
    • Eventi
    • Eunews Newsletter

    No Result
    View All Result
    • it ITA
    • en ENG
    • Politics
    • Newsletter
    • World politics
    • Business
    • General News
    • Defence & Security
    • Net & Tech
    • Agrifood
    • Altre sezioni
      • European Agenda
      • Culture
      • Diritti
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Gallery
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • News
      • Opinions
      • Sports
    • Director's Point of View
    • L’Europa come non l’avete mai ascoltata
    • Draghi Report
    • Eventi
    • Eunews Newsletter

    Attention

    We value your privacy
    We and our 1507 partners store and/or access information on a device, such as cookies and process personal data, such as unique identifiers and standard information sent by a device for personalised advertising and content, advertising and content measurement, audience research and services development. With your permission we and our 1507 partners may use precise geolocation data and identification through device scanning. You may click to consent to our and our 1507 partners’ processing as described above. Alternatively you may access more detailed information and change your preferences before consenting or to refuse consenting. Please note that some processing of your personal data may not require your consent, but you have a right to object to such processing. Your preferences will apply to this website only. You can change your preferences or withdraw your consent at any time by returning to this site and clicking the privacy policy button at the bottom of the webpage.