- Europe, like you've never read before -
Friday, 20 November 2026
No Result
View All Result
  • en ENG
  • it ITA
Eunews
  • Politics
  • World
  • Business
  • News
  • Defence
  • Health
  • Agrifood
  • Other sections
    • Culture
    • Rights
    • Energy
    • Green Economy
    • Finance & Insurance
    • Industry & Markets
    • Media
    • Mobility & Logistics
    • Net & Tech
    • Sports
  • Eunews Newsletter
  • European 2024
    Eunews
    • Politics
    • World
    • Business
    • News
    • Defence
    • Health
    • Agrifood
    • Other sections
      • Culture
      • Rights
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Net & Tech
      • Sports
    No Result
    View All Result
    Eunews
    No Result
    View All Result

    Home » General News » Covid‑19: EU Court’s Advocate General says Brussels lacked transparency on vaccine contracts

    Covid‑19: EU Court’s Advocate General says Brussels lacked transparency on vaccine contracts

    In his opinion, which is not binding on the European Court of Justice, Advocate General Athanasios Rantos said that the Commission should have made public the indemnification clauses and the names of the negotiators

    Valeria Schröter by Valeria Schröter
    11 June 2026
    in General News, Health
    CORTE DI GIUSTIZIA DELL'UNIONE EUROPEA UE CURIA

ESTERNO SEDE

    CORTE DI GIUSTIZIA DELL'UNIONE EUROPEA UE CURIAESTERNO SEDE

    Brussels – The European Commission “did not grant the public sufficiently broad access to agreements for the purchase of COVID-19 vaccines.” This is the conclusion reached today (11 June) by the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union, Athanasios Rantos, in his opinion on the transparency of contracts concluded by the EU executive for the purchase of Covid vaccines. 

    The Advocate pointed out that during the coronavirus pandemic, the European Union established a centralised mechanism for vaccine procurement to ensure a rapid and equitable supply to Member States. He also noted that, with the same objective in mind, the Commission had set up a joint negotiating team comprising some of its officials and a limited number of experts from the Member States, tasked with negotiating preliminary vaccine purchase agreements with certain pharmaceutical companies.

    In 2021, several Members of the European Parliament and various private individuals requested access to these agreements and the related documents. The Commission granted only partial access, redacting in particular the names of the members of the joint negotiating team and certain contractual indemnification clauses for pharmaceutical companies. The indemnity clauses, at the heart of the dispute, stipulated that Member States would reimburse pharmaceutical companies for any compensation they paid for damage caused by the vaccines.

    According to the Commission, the full disclosure of the information would have undermined the protection of the privacy and integrity of the individuals concerned, as well as the protection of the commercial interests of the companies involved. However, considering this level of access to be insufficient, MEPs and private individuals brought the matter before the General Court of the European Union, seeking annulment of the Commission’s decisions. In two judgments of 17 July 2024, the General Court ruled that the Commission had not granted the public sufficiently broad access to the contracts for the purchase of COVID-19 vaccines. In response, the Commission lodged an appeal with the Court of Justice, the higher court. 

    Advocate General Rantos – an independent legal expert who sits on the Court but does not vote on the judgment – proposed that the Court reject the Commission’s arguments
    and uphold the General Court’s judgment
    . The Advocate General’s opinion is not binding on the Court of Justice, which will now begin deliberations on this case and subsequently deliver a judgment. 

    Firstly, regarding the disclosure of personal data relating to members of the negotiation team, the Advocate General stated that “a natural person may obtain
    disclosure of such information where he or she demonstrates that such disclosure is necessary to pursue an objective in
    the public interest.” Rantos, therefore, considered that “
    the General Court was correct in holding that the transparency of the process of
    negotiating agreements for Covid-19 vaccines constitutes a specific purpose in the public interest within the meaning of
    EU law
    .” The Advocate General further stated “that solely the disclosure of anonymised versions of declarations of no of
    conflict of interests does not make it possible for the impartiality of the members of the negotiation team.”
     

    Secondly, with regard to the contractual clauses relating to indemnification of the pharmaceutical undertakings, Rantos proposed “that the Commission’s arguments, whereby the Commission claims that their disclosure would undermine the
    commercial interests of the undertakings concerned, be dismissed.”
     

    The Advocate General considered that the Commission did not demonstrate that the disclosure of the clauses relating to indemnification would be likely to encourage abusive strategic conduct or increase the risk of liability claims against the pharmaceutical undertakings. Specifically, he stressed that those clauses “do not affect the conditions for triggering liability of the undertakings towards injured third parties, but concern solely the reimbursement mechanisms that may apply between Member States and the undertakings following a possible finding of liability of those undertakings.”

    English version by the Translation Service of Withub
    Tags: commissionecourtgeneral counseluevaccines

    Related Posts

    Hantavirus - Tzitzikostas
    Health

    Hantavirus: EU clarifies contagion risk is very low, though more cases can’t be ruled out

    21 May 2026
    salute
    Health

    EU launches Global Health Resilience Initiative, with focus on ‘cooperation’

    13 May 2026
    map visualization
    Il primo ministro della Gran Bretagna, Andy Burnham, il presidente del Consiglio europeo, Antònio Costa, la presidente della Commissione europea, Ursula von der Leyen, prendono un tè informale al Summit UE-Regno Unito. Crediti: Consiglio dell'Unione europea

    Burnham declares Brexit a failure: “We want a better deal”

    by Iolanda Cuomo
    20 November 2026

    The British Prime Minister is in the Belgian capital for the second EU-UK Summit: “Today’s agreements cover the cost of...

    [Foto: Jérémie Mazenq. Copyright:
European Union , 2024

    Multiannual budget: EU Council reaches agreement in principle on a “stronger” civil protection mechanism

    by Emanuele Bonini emanuelebonini
    20 November 2026

    Member States have agreed on a more efficient emergency and crisis management mechanism. The outcome of the negotiations on the...

    Crediti foto: Sasun Bughdaryan via Unsplash

    EU sees record number of breast cancer prevention and treatment surgeries in 2024

    by Iolanda Cuomo
    20 November 2026

    Brussels – In 2024, there were 560,730 surgeries in the European Union to remove part of a mammary gland (partial excision) or...

    Sessione plenaria del Parlamento europeo a Strasburgo di luglio 2026. Crediti: Parlamento europeo

    EU budget, COP31, the cost-of-living crisis and – at last – a debate on Gaza: the European Parliament’s plenary agenda

    by Annachiara Magenta annacmag
    20 November 2026

    The next multiannual financial framework will dominate the debate among political groups. On Wednesday morning, MEPs will discuss the new...

    • Director’s Point of View
    • Opinions
    • About us
    • Contacts
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie policy

    Eunews is a registered newspaper
    Press Register of the Court of Turin n° 27

    Copyright © 2025 - WITHUB S.p.a., Via Savona 127/B, 20144 Milano
    VAT number: 10067080969 - ROC registration number n.30628
    Fully paid-up share capital 50.000,00€

     

    No Result
    View All Result
    • en ENG
    • it ITA
    • Politics
    • Newsletter
    • World politics
    • Business
    • General News
    • Defence & Security
    • Health
    • Agrifood
    • Altre sezioni
      • Culture
      • Rights
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Gallery
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Net & Tech
      • News
      • Opinions
      • Sports
    • Director’s Point of View
    • Draghi Report
    • Eunews Newsletter

    No Result
    View All Result
    • en ENG
    • it ITA
    • Politics
    • Newsletter
    • World politics
    • Business
    • General News
    • Defence & Security
    • Health
    • Agrifood
    • Altre sezioni
      • Culture
      • Rights
      • Energy
      • Green Economy
      • Gallery
      • Finance & Insurance
      • Industry & Markets
      • Media
      • Mobility & Logistics
      • Net & Tech
      • News
      • Opinions
      • Sports
    • Director’s Point of View
    • Draghi Report
    • Eunews Newsletter

    Attention